Here is the updated list of face products that I use. The ones with a heart icon () are of cruelty-free brands.
Face Soap: Dr. Bronner’s Baby Unscented Pure Castile Soap (liquid)
Eye Makeup Remover: The Body Shop Camomile Gentle Eye Makeup Remover
Toner: The Body Shop Aloe Vera Calming Toner
Zit Zapper: The Body Shop Tea Tree Oil Anti-Imperfection Daily Solution
Face Lotion: Yes To Cucumbers Soothing Daily Calming Moisturizer
BB Cream: NYX BB Cream (Nude)
Concealer: NYX Concealer Wand (Porcelain)
Foundation Powder: NYX #NOFILTER Finishing Powder (Alabaster)
Bronzer: HATE IT. Works great but too much scent, way too much. Need to find a new one. Physicians’ Formula Ultra Nourishing Argan Oil Bronzer
Blush: Joe Fresh Blush (Pink)
Eyebrow Pencil: Mary Kay Brow Definer Pencil
Mascara: Maybelline The Colossal Chaotic Lash Mascara
As you can see, I’ve replaced all but my mascara & eyebrow pencil brands. Those, I’m veeeeeeery particular about so HOPEFULLY, I do find some equally good replacements soon!